In NSW, you may be able to claim further provision even if you have been given a right to live in the home. The question is whether the overall arrangements adequately provide for your proper maintenance, education or advancement in life.
A right to occupy a house can be valuable. It does not necessarily provide the income, access to funds or flexibility a surviving spouse needs. Equally, receiving no cash under the will does not automatically mean further provision will be ordered. Your own resources and the circumstances of the estate also matter.
Can a surviving spouse claim more than a right of residence?
Yes, potentially. A person who was married to the deceased at death is eligible to apply for family provision under section 57 of the Succession Act 2006 (NSW). A person living in a de facto relationship with the deceased at death also falls within an eligible category.
Under section 59 of the Succession Act 2006 (NSW), the Supreme Court considers whether adequate provision has been made and, if not, what provision ought to be made.
You do not need to have been completely excluded. A claim may concern the adequacy of an existing benefit, including a restrictive right of occupation or a life interest that does not meet your needs.
You also do not necessarily need to challenge the validity of the will. A family provision claim can proceed on the basis that the will is valid but leaves you inadequately provided for.
What exactly has the will given you?
Before assessing a claim, we need to read the actual clause and the surrounding provisions. The expressions “right of residence” and “life interest” are sometimes used loosely. Their legal effect depends on the arrangement created by the will.
A right of residence or occupation
A right of residence commonly allows you to occupy a particular property for a stated period or until a specified event. It may be personal to you and subject to conditions.
For example, the will may require you to pay particular expenses or provide that the right ends if you permanently stop living there. It may contain conditions concerning remarriage or a new relationship. We need to consider the wording and legal effect of any condition rather than assume it is enforceable or has been triggered.
A right to live in the house does not necessarily let you rent it out, sell it, access its value or require the purchase of another home.
A life interest
A life interest generally gives you a beneficial interest for your lifetime, with the remaining interest passing to someone else afterwards. Depending on its terms and structure, it may provide broader benefits than a personal right to occupy, including an entitlement to income.
However, a life interest does not automatically give you unrestricted access to the capital or an independent power to sell the property. Powers to sell, reinvest or substitute accommodation need to be examined.
Outright ownership
Outright ownership generally gives much greater control, including the ability to sell and use the proceeds, subject to mortgages, co-ownership and other applicable restrictions.
It is important to establish what your spouse actually owned. If you already owned the home together, the title and form of ownership must be checked before assuming the will governs the whole property.
Why a roof over your head may not be enough
Accommodation is only one part of financial security. You still need to meet everyday expenses and cope with changes in health and circumstances.
An arrangement may look generous because the home is valuable, while leaving you with little money you can actually use. That can be particularly difficult if your spouse previously paid most household expenses or you reduced paid work to care for them.
Living expenses and access to money
A realistic assessment includes food, utilities, transport, insurance, medical expenses and other reasonable costs. It also considers your income, savings, superannuation and other resources.
The issue is not simply whether you can manage this month. Your age, health, earning capacity and foreseeable future needs can also be relevant.
Rates, repairs and maintenance
The will may allocate responsibility for rates, insurance, repairs or other outgoings. If it is silent or unclear, responsibility needs to be determined from the legal nature of the arrangement and applicable rules. It should not be assumed that either you or the estate must pay everything.
A right to remain in an ageing house can become difficult to use if you cannot afford the expenses attached to it. Obtain estimates for significant work rather than relying on broad assertions about future repairs.
Changes in accommodation needs
The home may become unsuitable because of stairs, maintenance demands, isolation or distance from family and medical services.
A fixed right to occupy one property may provide no workable means of moving elsewhere. Depending on the will, permanently leaving could also end the benefit. These issues should be considered before you surrender occupation, sign a release or agree to a sale.
If you need urgent medical care, prioritise your care and obtain advice promptly about protecting your position. A temporary hospital stay should not simply be assumed to have the same effect as permanently leaving the home.
What will the Court consider?
The matters listed in section 60 of the Succession Act 2006 (NSW) include the relationship, the deceased’s responsibilities, the estate’s assets and liabilities, financial resources and needs, age, disability, contributions and previous provision.
In practical terms, we need to understand both your finances and how the proposed arrangements would work. Can you afford the home? Who makes decisions about repairs? Can your accommodation change as your needs change? Are funds available for living expenses and unexpected costs?
The length and nature of the relationship matter, as do financial and non-financial contributions. Caring for your spouse, maintaining the home and supporting family life can be relevant even if the property was originally purchased by your spouse.
The assessment also includes benefits received outside the will or during the deceased’s lifetime. Receiving no cash under the will is not the same as having no financial resources.
Do my spouse’s children take priority over me?
There is no automatic rule that adult children must receive the capital while a surviving spouse receives only occupation of the home.
A spouse’s need for secure accommodation and financial support can carry substantial weight, particularly after a long relationship. Those needs may justify provision that reduces what adult children receive.
However, spouses do not automatically receive the whole estate or take priority in every case. The Court considers competing claims, including any children with disabilities, limited resources or other substantial needs.
In a blended family, the source of the assets, the relationship history and the deceased’s intentions may also be relevant. The fact that a house was owned before the relationship does not, by itself, prevent a claim involving it.
Can the Court give me ownership of the home?
In an appropriate case, outright ownership may be ordered. It is one possible outcome, not an automatic entitlement arising from marriage.
An illustration is Hertzberg v Hertzberg [2003] NSWCA 311. The NSW Court of Appeal upheld orders giving a surviving wife ownership of the home unit and a lump sum. The Court considered, among other matters, the limitations of her right of residence, the inability to substitute another home and difficulties surrounding repairs and ongoing arrangements with the beneficiaries.
That case involved a large estate and substantial other financial arrangements. It was decided under the earlier Family Provision Act 1982. It illustrates why the practical adequacy of accommodation matters, rather than establishing that every spouse with a right of residence should receive the house.
Your claim needs to be assessed on its own facts, including whether the estate can support the provision sought.
What other provision could be sought?
The Court has flexibility in structuring provision under section 65 of the Succession Act 2006 (NSW). Depending on the circumstances, possible outcomes include a lump sum, periodic payments, provision involving property, or a combination of benefits.
A negotiated settlement might retain your accommodation rights while providing funds for living expenses and contingencies. Alternatively, an arrangement may need to address replacement accommodation and clarify responsibility for outgoings.
The aim is to identify provision that works in practice. Simply changing the label from a right of residence to a life interest may not solve the underlying problem.
A portable life interest or Crisp order
In some cases, a more flexible accommodation arrangement can allow estate capital to be used for different accommodation as your needs change. This is commonly described as a portable life interest or a Crisp order.
The nature of such orders is discussed in Prior v Kerrison [2017] NSWSC 1295. Depending on its terms, an order can permit a home to be sold and funds used for replacement housing, retirement accommodation or nursing care accommodation.
This does not necessarily make the capital yours outright or allow unrestricted spending. The order needs to address how funds are held and applied, who makes decisions and what happens to remaining funds after your death.
A portable arrangement can sometimes accommodate both your changing needs and the interests of the beneficiaries who ultimately receive the capital.
What if the house is the estate’s main asset?
A lack of cash does not necessarily prevent a family provision claim. It does affect the options available and how any provision could be funded.
We need to establish the property’s value, any mortgage and other estate liabilities. We can then assess whether retaining the property, selling and purchasing less expensive accommodation, or another arrangement could meet your needs.
There may be no solution that gives everyone everything they want. Legal costs and the practical consequences of any proposed sale must also be considered, particularly in a modest estate.
What evidence will help my claim?
Start with the complete will and any correspondence from the executor about your occupation. If there is a separate agreement, trust document or proposed deed, provide that too.
Prepare a clear summary of your income, assets, debts and expenses, supported by records. Identify which expenses your spouse used to pay and what has changed since their death.
Evidence about the home may include title details, mortgage statements, rates and insurance notices, repair estimates and information about its suitability. If health affects your accommodation needs, medical or occupational therapy evidence may help explain the problem.
For future accommodation, realistic options and cost estimates are more useful than an unsupported request for a large sum. Your evidence should also explain the relationship, your contributions and any difficulties in operating the arrangements under the will.
What should I do now?
Obtain advice before assuming that the right of residence is all you can receive, or that you must accept new conditions proposed by the executor.
Under section 58 of the Succession Act 2006 (NSW), a family provision application generally must be filed within 12 months of death. That period does not run from the date you receive the will or realise the arrangement is inadequate.
If the deadline has passed, obtain advice promptly about whether an application out of time is available. Do not assume it will be allowed.
We can notify the executor of your intended claim and seek an appropriate undertaking about distribution. A letter does not stop the filing deadline or automatically freeze the estate. If your occupation is threatened, a sale is imminent or assets may be distributed, tell us immediately so we can assess what protection is needed.
How PB Ritz Lawyers can help
A right to live in the house should be assessed against the life you need to lead, including your financial position and changing accommodation needs.
PB Ritz Lawyers can review the will, explain the rights it gives you and assess whether further provision should be sought. We can help identify an appropriate outcome, prepare the supporting evidence and negotiate with the executor and beneficiaries. If agreement cannot be reached, we can advise on court proceedings and the associated costs risks.
No Win, No Fee arrangements are available for approved family provision claims, subject to our costs agreement. We will explain the terms, treatment of disbursements, circumstances in which payment may become due and the separate risk of an order to pay another party’s costs.
If your spouse left you accommodation but insufficient money or flexibility, contact PB Ritz Lawyers with the will and the date of death. We can assess whether the provision genuinely meets your needs and what steps should be taken next.
